WayBackJack All-Americans  
               
  Name Position Year(s) Poll  
               
  Anderson, Tom Defensive End 1969 3rd Team (AP)  
               
  Boettcher, Mike "Bo" Linebacker 1971 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Brown, Charlie Wide Receiver 1969 3rd Team (AP)  
               
  Clark, Allan Running Back 1978 CoSIDA Academic  
  Sporting News  
  AP  
               
  Daniel, Herb Quarterback 1977 CoSIDA Academic  
               
  Dansby, Cleveland Cornerbacks 1977 AP  
               
  Dejanovich, Owen Defensive Tackle 1963 NAIA  
               
  Duley, Ed Defensive Tackle 1968 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Friedrichs, Larry Offensive Guard 1976-77 2nd Team (AP)  
  1977 Kodak  
  CoSIDA Academic  
  Sporting News  
               
  Golden, Carl Running Back 1976-77 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Hanna, Bill Defensive End 1967 1st Team (AP)  
               
  Higginson, Neal Nose Guard 1978 AP  
  Sporting News  
               
  Hightower, Ed Defensive End 1977-78 CoSIDA Academic  
  1978 AP  
  Sporting News  
               
  Judie, Ed Linebacker 1979 AP  
               
  Jurich, Tom Kicker 1977 Kodak  
  Sporting News  
               
  Lomas, Mark Defensive end 1969 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Lumpkin, Jerry Linebacker 1977-78 AP  
  1978 CoSIDA Academic  
               
  Maier, Steve Wide Receiver 1970 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Mullen, Rufus Cornerback 1971-72 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Nuttall, John Offensive Guard 1971 2nd Team (AP)  
               
  O'Hara, Rich Wide Receiver 1967 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Ramsey, Tom Defensive End 1972 3rd Team (AP)  
               
  Reeves, Willard Running Back 1979 AP  
               
  Schultz, Kelly Tight End 1972 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Small, Larry Offensive Guard 1968 NAIA  
  1st Team (AP)  
               
  Smith, Harold Free Safety 1978 AP  
               
  Smith, Jimmy Running Back 1973 2nd Team (AP)  
               
  Stewart, Bob Quarterback 1969 Honorable Mention (AP)  
               
  Wiedoff, Bud Defensive End 1967-68 2nd Team (AP)  
               
  Willig, Chuck Defensive Back 1979 AP